Prompt: How do Elie's experiences during the Holocaust change him as a person?
Pages read: 65- 115 (end)
An effect the Holocaust had on Elie was the way he sees God and his humanity. In the beginning, Elie was very pious. Then throughout the book you can see Elie's transition as he starts to rebel against God and comes to the point where he no longer thinks God exists. The Holocaust also much affect on Elie's humanity. In the beginning he seems very joyful and happy but then throughout the book you can see his humanity change drastically.
In the beginning of the book Elie is very pious. He was very religious and devoted to God. In the book it says,"And Moishe the Beadle, the poorest of the poorest of Sighet, spoke to me for hours on end about Kabbalah's revelations and its mysteries. Thus began my initiation. Together we would read, over and over again, the same page of the Zohar. Not to learn it by heart but to discover within the very essence of divinity.(P.5 New Edition)" This quote really shows how he was so devoted to God. He would read the same page of the Zohar over and over just so that he could see its divinity. His father even told him he was still too young to start studying his religion so much. His father even tried to take that idea from his mind.
Later on when he entered the concentration camps he began to change. He begins to question God and his existence. Then he comes to the point where he loses all faith in him. In the book it says,"For the first time, I felt anger rising within me. Why should I sanctify His name? The Almighty, the eternal and terrible Master of the Universe, chose to be silent. What was there to thank Him for? (P.33)" He began to doubt God. He saw all these terrible things happening to people around him. He saw babies get burnt alive, people get shot, people get hanged, people starve to death, and yet God did nothing about it. He saw so many things and he doubted God because God did nothing to help them. He only watched. Then came the point where he lost all faith in him.
Another effect that the Holocaust had on Elie was that it took his humanity away. In the beginning of the book, Elie demonstrated to be very happy and religious. Though, as he entered he camps he lost his humanity. In the book, it says,"And he began beating him with an iron bar. At first, my father simply doubled over under the blows, but then he seemed to break in two like an old tree struck by lightning. I had watched it all happening without moving. I kept silent. (P.54)" Elie's humanity was taken from him. He saw his dad get beaten right in front of his eyes and did nothing about it. Instead of helping his dad up or get beaten in the place of his father, he just stood there and watched. He was practically paralyzed. Every time someone was shot or hanged, for him it was just the typical.
Wednesday, February 24, 2016
Thursday, February 18, 2016
Night Blog 2/18/16
Prompt: Prompt: Do any of the characters feeling change as you’ve read? Explain why or why not.
Pages: 0-65
Elie's feelings change a lot from what I've read so far. In the beginning of the story Elie is very religious and optimistic. When he lived in Poland (before the concentration camps) he very optimistic. He loved to study and learn about his religion even though people told him he was too young for that. He hanged out with Moishe the Beadle so he could learn more about his religion and the ways of life. His life seemed full of happiness and freedom until he entered the concentration camps. From there on, things went downfall.
Elie's faith in God changes a lot from what I've read so far. In the beginning, he would pray everyday to thank him for everything he's done. He was so devoted to his religion. In the book it says,"And Moishe the Beadle, the poorest of the poor of Sighet, spoke to me for hours on end about the Kabbalah's revelations and its mysteries. Thus began my initiation. Together we would read, over and over again, the same page of the Zohar. Not to learn it by heart but to discover within the very essence of divinity." (P.5 New Edition) This quote demonstrates how devoted Elie was to his religion in the beginning of the book. Afterwards, Elie gets put into a concentration camp and that makes him lose most of his faith. He begins to question God's existence. In the book he says,"For the first time, I felt anger rising within me. Why should I sanctify His name? The Almighty, the eternal and terrible Master of the Universe, chose to be silent. What was there to thank Him for?" (P.33 New Edition) This demonstrates how in the beginning Elie was very pious and then when he enters the concentration camps he slowly loses faith.
Not only does Elie begin to lose faith in his religion but he also becomes more melancholy like his attitude toward some events are different. For example, in the beginning of the book how happy he was to be studying his religion, etc. Though, later on he begins to change. He let his father be beaten up and slapped right in front of his face. He did not do anything to stop it. When Idek beat up his father, he wasn't mad at Idek for harming his father instead he was mad at his father for catching Idek's attention. Also it caught my attention how he reacted before the second hanging mentioned in the book. In the book it says,"The SS surrounding us, machine guns aimed at us: the usual ritual." It really shocked me how he mentioned that it was usual for them to be aimed at by guns. He says it like it's literally nothing just something usual.
Elie's feelings change a lot from what I've read so far. In the beginning of the story Elie is very religious and optimistic. When he lived in Poland (before the concentration camps) he very optimistic. He loved to study and learn about his religion even though people told him he was too young for that. He hanged out with Moishe the Beadle so he could learn more about his religion and the ways of life. His life seemed full of happiness and freedom until he entered the concentration camps. From there on, things went downfall.
Elie's faith in God changes a lot from what I've read so far. In the beginning, he would pray everyday to thank him for everything he's done. He was so devoted to his religion. In the book it says,"And Moishe the Beadle, the poorest of the poor of Sighet, spoke to me for hours on end about the Kabbalah's revelations and its mysteries. Thus began my initiation. Together we would read, over and over again, the same page of the Zohar. Not to learn it by heart but to discover within the very essence of divinity." (P.5 New Edition) This quote demonstrates how devoted Elie was to his religion in the beginning of the book. Afterwards, Elie gets put into a concentration camp and that makes him lose most of his faith. He begins to question God's existence. In the book he says,"For the first time, I felt anger rising within me. Why should I sanctify His name? The Almighty, the eternal and terrible Master of the Universe, chose to be silent. What was there to thank Him for?" (P.33 New Edition) This demonstrates how in the beginning Elie was very pious and then when he enters the concentration camps he slowly loses faith.
Not only does Elie begin to lose faith in his religion but he also becomes more melancholy like his attitude toward some events are different. For example, in the beginning of the book how happy he was to be studying his religion, etc. Though, later on he begins to change. He let his father be beaten up and slapped right in front of his face. He did not do anything to stop it. When Idek beat up his father, he wasn't mad at Idek for harming his father instead he was mad at his father for catching Idek's attention. Also it caught my attention how he reacted before the second hanging mentioned in the book. In the book it says,"The SS surrounding us, machine guns aimed at us: the usual ritual." It really shocked me how he mentioned that it was usual for them to be aimed at by guns. He says it like it's literally nothing just something usual.
Monday, February 15, 2016
AoW Impressions Blog 2/12/16
Prompt: Today you were educated by your peers as to different topics focusing on the Holocaust. Now take a moment to reflect upon your impressions of what you have learned from the array of articles in at least two well written paragraphs, using evidence from your graphic organizer.
Throughout this AoW gallery walk, I learned a lot about the Holocaust. There was many facts and stories of survivors that I had never heard of! The articles that mostly stood out to me was Diana's and Justin's. These two articles focus on two different points of view on the Holocaust. Diana's article is about a survivor of the Holocaust. Justin's article is about Holocaust survivors demanding that refugees should be let in. I found these two articles the most interesting.
Diana's article about a Holocaust survivor was really interesting, it caught my attention. Her article was about a Holocaust survivor who survived by playing the piano for the Nazi's. She played the piano for the Nazi's and one day her father rescued her. I don't remember what happened to her father but after she was rescued, she reunited with her sister. Though, when she was rescued the only thing she took with her was a sheet of music paper. After she was rescued her and her sister changed basically everything about them. For example, their names, passports, etc. Then one day when she decided to play the sheet of music she saved a Nazi heard her play. She ended up playing the piano in German shows. No one ever discovered she was a Jew though. I found this article very interesting due to the fact that she could have been discovered but wasn't. She was basically playing with fire.
Justin's article is about how Holocaust survivors demand that refugees should be let in. I found this very interesting because they most of all understand refugees pain and suffering. They understand how horrible it is to be discriminated against. Justin described how survivors saw photos of refugees and they were inspired to help them out. He also said how in order to help out the refugees it takes a group effort not only Jewish help. I agree with this because in order for all the refugees to have a home and food, it will take a lot of effort from many people. The Jewish can't just help by themselves, we have to put in our part too.
Throughout this AoW gallery walk, I learned a lot about the Holocaust. There was many facts and stories of survivors that I had never heard of! The articles that mostly stood out to me was Diana's and Justin's. These two articles focus on two different points of view on the Holocaust. Diana's article is about a survivor of the Holocaust. Justin's article is about Holocaust survivors demanding that refugees should be let in. I found these two articles the most interesting.
Diana's article about a Holocaust survivor was really interesting, it caught my attention. Her article was about a Holocaust survivor who survived by playing the piano for the Nazi's. She played the piano for the Nazi's and one day her father rescued her. I don't remember what happened to her father but after she was rescued, she reunited with her sister. Though, when she was rescued the only thing she took with her was a sheet of music paper. After she was rescued her and her sister changed basically everything about them. For example, their names, passports, etc. Then one day when she decided to play the sheet of music she saved a Nazi heard her play. She ended up playing the piano in German shows. No one ever discovered she was a Jew though. I found this article very interesting due to the fact that she could have been discovered but wasn't. She was basically playing with fire.
Justin's article is about how Holocaust survivors demand that refugees should be let in. I found this very interesting because they most of all understand refugees pain and suffering. They understand how horrible it is to be discriminated against. Justin described how survivors saw photos of refugees and they were inspired to help them out. He also said how in order to help out the refugees it takes a group effort not only Jewish help. I agree with this because in order for all the refugees to have a home and food, it will take a lot of effort from many people. The Jewish can't just help by themselves, we have to put in our part too.
Friday, February 12, 2016
Wednesday, February 3, 2016
Berlin Memorial Blog 2/4/16
Prompt:
1- What did you learn?
2- Why do you think this monument was built?
3- What did you notice about the number of laws passed in certain years?
4- Which restrictions do you think you would have the most trouble dealing with and why?
2- Why do you think this monument was built?
3- What did you notice about the number of laws passed in certain years?
4- Which restrictions do you think you would have the most trouble dealing with and why?
One of the many things I learn is how the Germans changed the whole lifestyle of the Jewish. The Germans made their lives almost impossible to live. They took away their entertainment, education, rights, jobs, etc. Basically it was almost impossible for them to live, they weren't able to do anything. Also, in some years they passed way more laws then in other years. In other years they passed a little bit of laws or in some years they didn't pass any laws at all. Throughout this activity I learned a lot about the Nuremberg Laws and how the Jewish lived back then.
I learned a lot about how difficult it was for the Jewish people to live back then. It was almost impossible since they really couldn't do anything for themselves. The Germans had literally restricted them from everything. They couldn't even work anymore, meaning they couldn't earn any money. Without any money they couldn't buy food, clothes, etc. Many Jewish people died because they weren't able to obtain their basic needs. These laws killed many Jewish. I learned all of the pain and suffering the Jewish had to through. I knew the Jewish went through much pain but I had no idea that they had suffered this much with the Nuremberg Laws.
I think that this monument was built because since in 1945 they destroyed all evidence of the Nuremberg laws they wanted to keep some evidence alive. They probably wanted to show some respect for all the misery the Jewish people had to go through. That's why they kept some evidence of the Nuremberg laws by putting them up on lampposts. Like a remembrance to all pain the Jewish people had to go through. The Germans probably felt bad for all they made them go through and they realized that all of Germany's problems weren't because of them. Since they had never done anything to Germany, I think this monument was built to remember all of the pain the Germans put the Jewish through.
I noticed that throughout the years there was some particular years in which there was many laws made. In some years there was barely or no laws made. There's an odd pattern throughout the years on the number of laws made. Though, I think that during the years that the most laws were made, there was some sort of uprising. I think this because why would they make so many laws in only one year? I think the Jewish were trying to make an uprising but the Nazis stopped them by making more laws which made it more complicated for them to make some sort of uprising.
I think that the restrictions I would have the most trouble with would be being expelled from sport clubs (1933) and that Aryan and non-Aryan kids wouldn't be able to play together (1938). I would have trouble with not being able to play in sport because I'm athletic. My favorite sport is soccer and for me it would be difficult not being able to play that anymore just because of my religion. The law itself doesn't even make sense. Also, I would have trouble not being able to play with other kids because honestly I can talk to anyone no matter what religion they are. I'm not a very social person but to me religion doesn't matter as long as you're nice to me, I'll treat you nicely too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)